Anthony Geraci’s Why Did You Have To Go is a masterpiece of original Blues, and features an unparalleled array of musical talent: Sugaray Rayford, Ronnie Earl, Monster Mike Welch, Sugar Ray Norcia, Kid Ramos, Jimi Bott, Willie J. Campbell, Michelle “Evil Gal” Willson, Dennis Brennan, Michael Mudcat Ward, Doug Woolverton, Willie J. Laws, Brian Templeton, Sax Gordon, Marty Richards, Troy Gonyea, and Neil Gouvin.
This is pure blues, rendered by the many of its best players, It’s every bit as good as Fifty Shades of Blue. That’s saying plenty. This is as good as the blues gets.
- Jim Hynes, Elmore Magazine September 2018
“...every song makes an emphatic impression courtesy of a superb group of studio musicians who adeptly punctuate every note and nuance of Geraci's original tunes...Why Did You Have to Go is more than the sum of its parts. A superb set of songs. Each number offers ample reason to return for repeat listens.”
- Lee Zimmerman, Living Blues
“There is so much to enjoy on this recording from the fresh, varied material from Geraci, his own consistently strong playing, a solid studio band and terrific singing and playing. Why Did You Have To Go is superb.”
- Ron Weinstock, In A Blue Mood
Altogether a blues album of the highest order, the set actually closes with several of these masters of their craft exchanging ideas and blending wonderfully within the breezy, beautiful jazz of “A Minor, Affair.” The players certainly say it all here, but the songcraft too lifts Why Did You Have To Go into the category of extraordinary blues albums.
- Tom Clarke, Tahoe Onstage
One of our biggest joys is listening to the versatile Geraci as his music is always new and refreshing. This jam packed album should further elevate Geraci as he continues his musical journey.
- Richard Ludmerer, Making A Scene September 2018
"You're a heck of a piano player"
- B.B. King
Geraci’s exquisite piano work has been spotlighted in the past with Sugar Ray & The Bluetones and with Ronnie Earl & The Broadcasters. As impressive as those gigs were, nothing prepared me for this album from Anthony Geraci and the Boston Blues All-Stars.
- Mark E. Gallo, Blues Bytes September 2015
The album lives up to its title as the gathered faithful tear it up through country blues, pop-inflected blues, jazz, ragtime, and driving rock and pure gut-wrenching power blues.- Henry L. Carrigan, Jr., Blues Blast Magazine May 2016
Fifty Shades Of Blue